Metal Roofing vs. Shingles: A Comprehensive Comparison


In the vast realm of roofing, two primary contenders emerge as popular choices for homeowners and contractors alike: metal roofing and shingles. Here at Home Evolution, an esteemed Albany NY roofing company, we often find ourselves addressing the nuances of both materials. Each offers unique advantages and challenges. This guide delves deep into these details, aiming to arm you with the knowledge to make the right choice for your property.

Introduction to Roofing Materials

Understanding the foundation is pivotal. Metal roofing typically consists of panels formed from materials like zinc, copper, steel, or aluminum. Shingles, meanwhile, are commonly asphalt-based but can also be derived from wood, slate, or composite materials. As one of the leading Albany NY roofing contractors, Home Evolution has experience installing both types on a variety of homes.

Advantages of Metal Roofing

Superior Longevity

Metal roofs, installed by reputable Albany NY roofing companies such as Home Evolution, promise durability. They can serve a property for anywhere between 40 to 70 years, outlasting traditional asphalt shingles that generally last up to 20 years.

Enhanced Weather Resistance

Metal roofs stand firm against severe weather conditions. Their surfaces efficiently shed rain and snow, ensuring no water accumulation.

Fire Resistant Properties

Safety is paramount, and metal’s non-combustible nature offers excellent protection against fires.

Energy Efficiency

Reflecting solar radiant heat, metal roofs can cut cooling expenses by up to 25%.

Advantages of Shingles


For homeowners operating within a budget, shingles, especially asphalt ones, usually emerge as the more economical initial option.

Versatility in Design

With a myriad of colors, styles, and textures, shingles facilitate greater customization.

Easier Installation

In comparison to metal roofs, the installation process for shingles is simpler and faster.

Sound Insulation

Quality shingles ensure a tranquil indoor ambiance.

Cost Comparison

While shingles might present an attractive initial price point, the extended lifespan and decreased maintenance of metal roofs could tip the scales in the long run. Metal roofing can cost between $150 to $600 per square, while shingle roofing is often priced between $90 to $100 per square.

Lifespan & Durability

The longevity of metal roofs, spanning 40-70 years, clearly overshadows shingle roofs that last 20-30 years.

Aesthetic Appeal

Metal roofs provide a sleek, modern appearance, whereas shingles cater to traditional aesthetics.

Environmental Impact & Energy Efficiency

Metal roofs excel in energy efficiency. They’re also environment-friendly, often crafted from recycled materials and are completely recyclable at the end of their life. Conversely, asphalt shingles contribute more to landfill waste.

Maintenance & Repairs

Though metal roofs demand minimal maintenance, repairs can be pricier than shingles. Shingle roofs, while necessitating frequent care, are generally more economical to fix.

Installation Factors

While metal roofs mandate expertise for installation, shingles offer a more forgiving installation process.


In the contest of metal roofing vs. shingles, the verdict largely depends on individual requirements. Both options, when installed by a proficient roofing company in Albany NY, guarantee value. Your choice between the modern appeal of metal and the timeless charm of shingles will dictate your home’s roofing future.